Решение по делу № 2-981/2016 от 01.12.2016

РП_аЎ±_б________________>___юя    _________________p___________s_______юяяя____o___яяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяяямҐБ_[Ђ____р_ї_______________v‰____bjbj¬ъ¬ъ______________________=?��Ођ__Ођ__»7______________________________яя__________яя__________яя__________________·_____\ ______\ __ѕ_______ѕ_______ѕ_______ѕ_______ѕ_______________яяяя____Т_______Т_______Т_______Т___T___&___4___Т_______Е___ш___Z_______Z_______Z_______Z_______Z_______m_______m_______m_______8_______:_______:_______:_______:_______:_______:_______Ѕ___ў____"__b___:___E___________________ѕ_______m_______________________i_______m_______m_______m_______:_______________ѕ_______ѕ_______Z_______________Z______________е_______е_______е_______m___R___ѕ_______Z_______ѕ_______Z_______8_______________е_______________________________________________________m_______8_______________е_______е_______4_______________________________________________________________________________\_______Z_______яяяя____@І?_^’Т_________Т_______ї___о___L_______________$_______•___0___Е_______T_______Б"_____________Б"______\_______________________________________________________________________\_______Б"______________ѕ_______p___ґ___m_______m_______е_______m_______m_______________________________________m_______m_______m_______:_______:_______________________________________Й_______________________________________m_______m_______m_______Е_______m_______m_______m_______m_______________яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____________яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____яяяя____Б"______m_______m_______m_______m_______m_______m_____________________????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????

__„___:___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________5_;_>_ __! _2_-_9_0_7_/_1_6_

_______"_______ _ ___(_________

___<_5_=_5_<_ _ _>_A_A_8_9_A_:_>_9_ _$_5_4_5_@_0_F_8_8_

_

_3_._ _#_@_C_A_-___0_@_B_0_=_._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _2_1_ _4_5_:_0_1_@_O_ _2_0_1_6_ _3_>_4_0_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

_

_    _#_@_C_A_-___0_@_B_0_=_>_2_A_:_8_9_ _3_>_@_>_4_A_:_>_9_ _A_C_4_ _"_5_G_5_=_A_:_>_9_ _ _5_A_?_C_1_;_8_:_8_ _2_ _A_>_A_B_0_2_5_:_ _

_?_@_5_4_A_5_4_0_B_5_;_L_A_B_2_C_N_I_5_3_>_ _A_C_4_L_8_ __ _!_0_=_3_0_@_8_5_2_0_ ___.___._,_ _

_?_@_8_ _A_5_:_@_5_B_0_@_5_ __ ___A_;_0_E_0_=_>_2_>_9_ ___.___._,_

_A_ _C_G_0_A_B_8_5_<_:_ _

_?_@_5_4_A_B_0_2_8_B_5_;_O_ _8_A_B_F_0_ _-_ ___C_1_0_9_@_0_5_2_0_ ___.___._,_ _4_5_9_A_B_2_C_N_I_5_3_>_ _?_>_ _A_?_5_F_8_0_;_L_=_>_9_ _4_>_2_5_@_5_=_=_>_A_B_8_ _2_K_4_0_=_=_>_9_ _A_@_>_:_>_<_ _4_>_ _6_ _>_:_B_O_1_@_O_ _2_0_2_0_ _3_>_4_0_,_

_@_0_A_A_<_>_B_@_5_2_ _2_ _>_B_:_@_K_B_>_<_ _A_C_4_5_1_=_>_<_ _7_0_A_5_4_0_=_8_8_ _3_@_0_6_4_0_=_A_:_>_5_ _4_5_;_>_ _?_>_ _8_A_:_C_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _____ _«_ _>_A_A_8_9_A_:_>_3_>_ _!_5_;_L_A_:_>_E_>_7_O_9_A_B_2_5_=_=_>_3_>_ _1_0_=_:_0_»_ _:_ _ _ _%_0_A_0_5_2_C_ ___;_8_E_0_=_C_ _!_C_;_B_0_=_>_2_8_G_C_,_ ___C_G_8_3_>_2_C_ _ _C_A_;_0_=_C_ ___;_0_<_0_B_>_2_8_G_C_ _8_ ___0_H_0_5_2_C_ ___0_3_>_<_5_4_-___;_8_ _%_0_A_-___0_3_>_<_5_4_>_2_8_G_C_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _>_ _2_7_K_A_:_0_=_8_8_ _7_0_4_>_;_6_5_=_=_>_A_B_8_ _ _?_>_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_=_>_<_C_ _4_>_3_>_2_>_@_C_._

_

_#_!_"_____________:_

_

_    _____ _«_ _>_A_A_8_9_A_:_8_9_ _!_5_;_L_A_:_>_E_>_7_O_9_A_B_2_5_=_=_K_9_ _1_0_=_:_»_ _2_ _;_8_F_5_ _4_>_?_>_;_=_8_B_5_;_L_=_>_3_>_ _>_D_8_A_0_ _"_5_G_5_=_A_:_>_3_>_ _@_5_3_8_>_=_0_;_L_=_>_3_>_ _D_8_;_8_0_;_0_ _____ _«_ _>_A_A_5_;_L_E_>_7_1_0_=_:_»_ _2_ _3_._ _#_@_C_A_-___0_@_B_0_=_ _!_0_B_C_5_2_0_ ___._!_._,_ _4_0_;_5_5_ _?_>_ _B_5_:_A_B_C_ _«___@_5_4_8_B_>_@_»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

_!_>_3_;_0_A_=_>_ _?_C_=_:_B_0_ _1_._1_ ___@_5_4_8_B_=_>_3_>_ _4_>_3_>_2_>_@_0_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_>_@_ _>_1_O_7_C_5_B_A_O_ _?_@_5_4_>_A_B_0_2_8_B_L_ _7_0_5_<_I_8_:_C_ _4_5_=_5_6_=_K_5_ _A_@_5_4_A_B_2_0_,_ _0_ _7_0_5_<_I_8_:_ _>_1_O_7_C_5_B_A_O_ _2_>_7_2_@_0_B_8_B_L_ _?_>_;_C_G_5_=_=_C_N_ _4_5_=_5_6_=_C_N_ _A_C_<_<_C_ _8_ _C_?_;_0_B_8_B_L_ _?_@_>_F_5_=_B_K_ _=_0_ _=_5_5_._ _

_ _0_A_?_>_@_O_6_5_=_8_5_<_ _#_?_@_0_2_;_O_N_I_5_3_>_ _4_>_?_>_;_=_8_B_5_;_L_=_>_3_>_ _>_D_8_A_0_ _"_5_G_5_=_A_:_>_3_>_ _ _$_ _____ _«_ _>_A_A_5_;_L_E_>_7_1_0_=_:_»_ _2_ _3_._ _#_@_C_A_-___0_@_B_0_=_ _>_ _?_@_5_4_>_A_B_0_2_;_5_=_8_8_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_0_,_ _A_>_ _A_A_C_4_=_>_3_>_ _A_G_5_B_0_ _>_B_:_@_K_B_>_3_>_ _4_;_O_ _>_B_@_0_6_5_=_8_O_ _>_?_5_@_0_F_8_9_ _?_>_ _2_K_4_0_G_5_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_0_,_ _=_0_ _;_8_F_5_2_>_9_ _A_G_5_B_ _%_0_A_0_5_2_0_ ___._!_._,_ _>_B_:_@_K_B_>_<_ _2_ _4_>_?_>_;_=_8_B_5_;_L_=_>_<_ _>_D_8_A_5_ _"_5_G_5_=_A_:_>_3_>_ _@_5_3_8_>_=_0_;_L_=_>_3_>_ _D_8_;_8_0_;_0_ _____ _«_ _>_A_A_5_;_L_E_>_7_1_0_=_:_»_ _2_ _3_._ _#_@_C_A_-___0_@_B_0_=_,_ _?_5_@_5_G_8_A_;_5_=_0_ _A_C_<_<_0_ _?_@_5_4_>_A_B_0_2_;_5_=_=_>_3_>_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_0_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _2_ _@_0_7_<_5_@_5_ _4_3_0_._0_0_0_ _(_G_5_B_K_@_5_A_B_0_ _B_@_8_4_F_0_B_L_ _B_K_A_O_G_)_ _@_C_1_;_5_9_ _0_0_ _:_>_?_5_5_:_._

___ _B_5_G_5_=_8_5_ _4_5_9_A_B_2_8_O_ ___@_5_4_8_B_=_>_3_>_ _4_>_3_>_2_>_@_0_ ___0_5_<_I_8_:_0_<_8_ _A_8_A_B_5_<_0_B_8_G_5_A_:_8_ _4_>_?_C_A_:_0_;_8_A_L_ _=_0_@_C_H_5_=_8_O_ _A_@_>_:_0_ _C_?_;_0_B_K_ _5_6_5_<_5_A_O_G_=_>_3_>_ _?_;_0_B_5_6_0_ _?_>_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_C_._ _

_

_!_ _0_?_@_5_;_O_ _2_0_1_5_ _3_>_4_0_ ___0_5_<_I_8_:_ _4_>_?_C_A_B_8_;_ _?_@_>_A_@_>_G_:_C_ _8_ _2_ _A_@_>_:_,_ _>_?_@_5_4_5_;_5_=_=_K_9_ _4_>_3_>_2_>_@_>_<_,_ _=_5_ _C_?_;_0_B_8_;_ _?_@_>_F_5_=_B_K_ _8_ _=_5_ _?_>_3_0_H_0_5_B_ _>_A_=_>_2_=_>_9_ _4_>_;_3_ _?_>_ _=_0_A_B_>_O_I_5_5_ _2_@_5_<_O_._

_    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

_!_@_>_:_ _?_>_3_0_H_5_=_8_O_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_0_ _A_>_3_;_0_A_=_>_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_=_>_<_C_ _4_>_3_>_2_>_@_C_ __!1_3_3_4_0_9_1_/_0_4_1_4_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _>_B_ _2_9_ _8_N_;_O_ _2_0_1_3_ _3_>_4_0_,_ _=_0_A_B_C_?_0_5_B_ _2_0_ _8_N_;_O_ _2_0_1_8_ _3_>_4_0_._ _

___ _A_>_>_B_2_5_B_A_B_2_8_8_ _?_._ _4_._7_._ _:_@_5_4_8_B_=_>_3_>_ _4_>_3_>_2_>_@_0_ _!_B_>_@_>_=_K_ _C_A_B_0_=_>_2_8_;_8_,_ _G_B_>_ ___@_5_4_8_B_>_@_ _2_?_@_0_2_5_ _2_ _>_4_=_>_A_B_>_@_>_=_=_5_<_ _?_>_@_O_4_:_5_ _?_>_B_@_5_1_>_2_0_B_L_ _>_B_ ___0_5_<_I_8_:_0_ _4_>_A_@_>_G_=_>_3_>_ _2_>_7_2_@_0_B_0_ ___@_5_4_8_B_0_,_ _0_ _B_0_:_6_5_ _C_?_;_0_B_K_ _?_@_>_F_5_=_B_>_2_ _7_0_ _2_@_5_<_O_ _D_0_:_B_8_G_5_A_:_>_3_>_ _8_A_?_>_;_L_7_>_2_0_=_8_O_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_0_ _2_ _A_;_5_4_C_N_I_8_E_ _A_;_C_G_0_O_E_:_

_4_._7_._1_._ ___A_;_8_ ___0_5_<_I_8_:_ _=_5_ _8_A_?_>_;_=_8_B_ _8_;_8_ _8_A_?_>_;_=_8_B_ _=_5_=_0_4_;_5_6_0_I_8_<_ _>_1_@_0_7_>_<_,_ _E_>_B_O_ _1_K_ _>_4_=_C_ _8_7_ _?_5_@_5_G_8_A_;_5_=_=_K_E_ _=_8_6_5_ _>_1_O_7_0_=_=_>_A_B_5_9_:_

_-_ _>_1_O_7_0_=_=_>_A_B_L_ _2_ _A_@_>_:_ _2_>_7_2_@_0_I_0_B_L_ ___@_5_4_8_B_ _8_;_8_ _C_?_;_0_G_8_2_0_B_L_ _=_0_G_8_A_;_5_=_=_K_5_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _=_0_ _=_5_3_>_ _?_@_>_F_5_=_B_K_;_

_-_ _>_1_O_7_0_=_=_>_A_B_L_ _8_A_?_>_;_L_7_>_2_0_B_L_ _?_>_;_C_G_5_=_=_K_5_ _>_B_ ___@_5_4_8_B_>_@_0_ _4_5_=_5_6_=_K_5_ _A_@_5_4_A_B_2_0_ _8_A_:_;_N_G_8_B_5_;_L_=_>_ _=_0_ _F_5_;_8_,_ _C_A_B_0_=_>_2_;_5_=_=_K_5_ _=_0_A_B_>_O_I_8_<_ ___>_3_>_2_>_@_>_<_._

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

___ _C_A_B_0_=_>_2_;_5_=_=_K_9_ _2_ _B_@_5_1_>_2_0_=_8_8_ _A_@_>_:_ ___0_5_<_I_8_:_ _4_>_;_3_ _=_5_ _?_>_3_0_A_8_;_,_ _?_@_>_F_5_=_B_K_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _=_5_ _C_?_;_0_B_8_;_._

___0_ _<_>_<_5_=_B_ _>_1_@_0_I_5_=_8_O_ _2_ _A_C_4_,_ _7_0_4_>_;_6_5_=_=_>_A_B_L_ _%_0_A_0_5_2_0_ ___;_8_E_0_=_0_ _!_C_;_B_0_=_>_2_8_G_0_ _ _?_5_@_5_4_ ___0_=_:_>_<_ _A_>_A_B_0_2_;_O_5_B_ __ _3_5_4_._9_6_5_ _(_B_@_8_A_B_0_ _?_O_B_L_4_5_A_O_B_ _G_5_B_K_@_5_ _B_K_A_O_G_0_ _4_5_2_O_B_L_A_>_B_ _H_5_A_B_L_4_5_A_O_B_ _?_O_B_L_)_ _@_C_1_;_5_9_ _0_4_ _:_>_?_5_5_:_._

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

_!_>_3_;_0_A_=_>_ _?_C_=_:_B_0_ _2_._1_._ _C_:_0_7_0_=_=_>_3_>_ _4_>_3_>_2_>_@_0_ _?_>_@_C_G_8_B_5_;_L_ _8_ _4_>_;_6_=_8_:_ _>_B_2_5_G_0_N_B_ _?_5_@_5_4_ ___@_5_4_8_B_>_@_>_<_ _A_>_;_8_4_0_@_=_>_._

___5_>_4_=_>_:_@_0_B_=_>_ _C_2_5_4_>_<_;_5_=_=_K_5_ _>_ _<_5_A_B_5_ _8_ _2_@_5_<_5_=_8_ _@_0_A_A_<_>_B_@_5_=_8_O_ _4_5_;_0_ _>_B_2_5_B_G_8_:_8_ _%_0_A_0_5_2_ ___._!_._,_ ___C_G_8_3_>_2_ _ _.___._ _8_ ___0_H_0_5_2_ ___-___._%_.___._,_ _2_ _A_C_4_5_1_=_>_5_ _7_0_A_5_4_0_=_8_5_ _=_5_ _O_2_8_;_8_A_L_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _8_ _=_5_ _?_@_>_A_8_;_8_ _>_ _@_0_A_A_<_>_B_@_5_=_8_8_ _4_5_;_0_ _2_ _8_E_ _>_B_A_C_B_A_B_2_8_5_._ _

_!_C_4_ _A_ _C_G_5_B_>_<_ _E_>_4_0_B_0_9_A_B_2_0_ _?_@_5_4_A_B_0_2_8_B_5_;_O_ _8_A_B_F_0_ _>_ _@_0_A_A_<_>_B_@_5_=_8_8_ _4_5_;_0_ _1_5_7_ _C_G_0_A_B_8_O_ _>_B_2_5_B_G_8_:_>_2_ _>_?_@_5_4_5_;_8_;_ _E_>_4_0_B_0_9_A_B_2_>_ _C_4_>_2_;_5_B_2_>_@_8_B_L_ _8_ _@_0_A_A_<_>_B_@_5_B_L_ _4_5_;_>_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _2_ _?_>_@_O_4_:_5_ _7_0_>_G_=_>_3_>_ _?_@_>_8_7_2_>_4_A_B_2_0_._

_    ___ _A_C_4_5_1_=_>_<_ _7_0_A_5_4_0_=_8_8_ _?_@_5_4_A_B_0_2_8_B_5_;_L_ _8_A_B_F_0_ _?_@_>_A_8_;_ _@_0_A_B_>_@_3_=_C_B_L_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_=_K_9_ _4_>_3_>_2_>_@_ _8_ _2_7_K_A_:_0_B_L_ _2_ _?_>_;_L_7_C_ _____ _«_ _>_A_A_8_9_A_:_8_9_ _!_5_;_L_A_:_>_E_>_7_O_9_A_B_2_5_=_=_K_9_ _1_0_=_:_»_ _2_ _;_8_F_5_ _4_>_?_>_;_=_8_B_5_;_L_=_>_3_>_ _>_D_8_A_0_ _"_5_G_5_=_A_:_>_3_>_ _@_5_3_8_>_=_0_;_L_=_>_3_>_ _D_8_;_8_0_;_0_ _____ _«_ _>_A_A_5_;_L_E_>_7_1_0_=_:_»_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _2_ _3_._ _#_@_C_A_-___0_@_B_0_=_ _A_>_;_8_4_0_@_=_>_ _A_ _%_0_A_0_5_2_0_ ___;_8_E_0_=_0_ _!_C_;_B_0_=_>_2_8_G_0_,_ ___C_G_8_3_>_2_0_ _ _C_A_;_0_=_0_ ___;_0_<_0_B_>_2_8_G_0_ _8_ ___0_H_0_5_2_0_ ___0_3_>_<_5_4_-___;_8_ _%_0_A_-___0_3_>_<_5_4_>_2_8_G_0_ _7_0_4_>_;_6_5_=_=_>_A_B_L_ _?_>_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_=_>_<_C_ _4_>_3_>_2_>_@_C_ _2_ _A_C_<_<_5_ __ _3_5_4_._9_6_5_ _(_B_@_8_A_B_0_ _?_O_B_L_4_5_A_O_B_ _G_5_B_K_@_5_ _B_K_A_O_G_0_ _4_5_2_O_B_L_A_>_B_ _H_5_A_B_L_4_5_A_O_B_ _?_O_B_L_)_ _@_C_1_;_5_9_ _ _0_4_ _:_>_?_5_5_:_,_ _0_ _B_0_:_6_5_ _@_0_A_E_>_4_K_ _?_>_ _C_?_;_0_B_5_ _3_>_A_C_4_0_@_A_B_2_5_=_=_>_9_ _?_>_H_;_8_=_K_ _2_ _A_C_<_<_5_ __ _6_._7_4_9_ _(_H_5_A_B_L_ _B_K_A_O_G_0_ _A_5_<_L_A_>_B_ _A_>_@_>_:_ _4_5_2_O_B_L_)_ _@_C_1_;_5_9_ _6_5_ _:_>_?_5_5_:_._ ___A_5_3_>_ _2_ _>_1_I_5_9_ _A_C_<_<_5_-_ _3_6_1_._7_1_4_ _(_B_@_8_A_B_0_ _H_5_A_B_L_4_5_A_O_B_ _>_4_=_0_ _B_K_A_O_G_0_ _A_5_<_L_A_>_B_ _G_5_B_K_@_=_0_4_F_0_B_L_)_ _@_C_1_;_5_9_ _6_9_ _:_>_?_5_5_:_

___7_C_G_8_2_ _<_0_B_5_@_8_0_;_K_ _4_5_;_0_,_ _8_A_A_;_5_4_>_2_0_2_ _?_@_8_2_5_4_5_=_=_K_5_ _?_>_ _4_5_;_C_ _4_>_:_0_7_0_B_5_;_L_A_B_2_0_,_ _A_C_4_ _?_@_8_E_>_4_8_B_ _:_ _2_K_2_>_4_C_ _>_ _=_5_>_1_E_>_4_8_<_>_A_B_8_ _C_4_>_2_;_5_B_2_>_@_5_=_8_O_ _8_A_:_0_ _?_>_ _A_;_5_4_C_N_I_8_<_ _>_A_=_>_2_0_=_8_O_<_._ _

_    _!_>_3_;_0_A_=_>_ _?_._1_ _A_B_._ _9_ _____ _ _$_ _3_@_0_6_4_0_=_5_ _8_ _N_@_8_4_8_G_5_A_:_8_5_ _;_8_F_0_ _?_>_ _A_2_>_5_<_C_ _C_A_<_>_B_@_5_=_8_N_ _>_A_C_I_5_A_B_2_;_O_N_B_ _?_@_8_=_0_4_;_5_6_0_I_8_5_ _8_<_ _3_@_0_6_4_0_=_A_:_8_5_ _?_@_0_2_0_._

_    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

_    _!_>_3_;_0_A_=_>_ _A_B_._A_B_._ _3_0_7_ _-_ _3_2_8_ _____ _ _$_ _>_1_O_7_0_B_5_;_L_A_B_2_0_ _4_>_;_6_=_K_ _8_A_?_>_;_=_O_B_L_A_O_ _=_0_4_;_5_6_0_I_8_<_ _>_1_@_0_7_>_<_ _2_ _C_A_B_0_=_>_2_;_5_=_=_K_9_ _A_@_>_:_,_ _>_4_=_>_A_B_>_@_>_=_=_8_9_ _>_B_:_0_7_ _>_B_ _8_A_?_>_;_=_5_=_8_O_ _>_1_O_7_0_B_5_;_L_A_B_2_ _=_5_4_>_?_C_A_B_8_<_._ _

_!_>_3_;_0_A_=_>_ _A_B_._ _3_2_3_ _____ _ _$_ _?_@_8_ _A_>_;_8_4_0_@_=_>_9_ _>_1_O_7_0_=_=_>_A_B_8_ _4_>_;_6_=_8_:_>_2_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_>_@_ _2_?_@_0_2_5_ _B_@_5_1_>_2_0_B_L_ _8_A_?_>_;_=_5_=_8_O_ _:_0_:_ _>_B_ _2_A_5_E_ _4_>_;_6_=_8_:_>_2_ _A_>_2_<_5_A_B_=_>_,_ _B_0_:_ _8_ _>_B_ _;_N_1_>_3_>_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _8_7_ _=_8_E_ _2_ _>_B_4_5_;_L_=_>_A_B_8_,_ _?_@_8_B_>_<_ _:_0_:_ _?_>_;_=_>_A_B_L_N_,_ _B_0_:_ _8_ _2_ _G_0_A_B_8_ _4_>_;_3_0_._ _

_!_>_3_;_0_A_=_>_ _A_B_._ _3_6_1_ _____ _ _$_ _?_>_ _4_>_3_>_2_>_@_C_ _?_>_@_C_G_8_B_5_;_L_A_B_2_0_ _?_>_@_C_G_8_B_5_;_L_ _>_1_O_7_C_5_B_A_O_ _?_5_@_5_4_ _:_@_5_4_8_B_>_@_>_<_ _4_@_C_3_>_3_>_ _;_8_F_0_ _>_B_2_5_G_0_B_L_ _7_0_ _=_5_8_A_?_>_;_=_5_=_8_5_ _?_>_A_;_5_4_=_8_<_ _5_3_>_ _>_1_O_7_0_B_5_;_L_A_B_2_0_ _?_>_;_=_>_A_B_L_N_ _8_;_8_ _2_ _G_0_A_B_8_._

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v___x___z___Љ___ю____    __*    __>    __@    __T    __Z    __\    __ь    ___
__"
__$
__фйЮфУЕ·¬ћ“·€·}rg·\·OE;______hZcУ_CJ__KH__aJ_____h__a_CJ__KH__aJ_____h?%Y&#0;_h¶8†&#0;CJ_&#0;KH_&#0;aJ_&#0;&#0;__h-&µ&#0;CJ_&#0;KH_&#0;\_ЃaJ____h(W _CJ__KH__\_ЃaJ____h$_u_CJ__KH__\_ЃaJ____h_gу_CJ__KH__\_ЃaJ____hЯ_^_CJ__KH__\_ЃaJ____hZcУ_CJ__KH__\_ЃaJ____h?%Y&#0;_h(W &#0;CJ_&#0;KH_&#0;\_ЃaJ____h¶8†_CJ__KH__\_ЃaJ____h?%Y&#0;_h¶8†&#0;CJ_&#0;KH_&#0;\_ЃaJ____h?%Y&#0;_h¶8†&#0;5_ЃCJ__KH__aJ____h“} _5_ЃCJ__KH__aJ____h__a_5_ЃCJ__KH__aJ____h(W _5_ЃCJ__KH__aJ____hЯ_^_5_ЃCJ__KH__aJ________ ___@___x___z___ь    __ю    __‚

__в

__&
__@
__0

__ґ___¶___М___О___ј___0___ў___®___ф____________м____________б____________б____________б____________Щ____________О____________О____________О____________О____________О____________Ж____________ѕ____________б____________б____________і____________§____________§____________§____________________
___$__„Р_`„Р_a$_gdf"5__

___$__d____a$_gd(W __ ___d____gd ;О__ ___$_a$_gd ;О__

___$__d____a$_gdZcУ__ ___d____gdZcУ__

___$__d____a$_gdZcУ__ ___d____gdZcУ__

___$__d____a$_gdЯ_^___$
__&
__h
__l
__Љ
___

2-981/2016

Категория:
Гражданские
Статус:
Иск (заявление, жалоба) УДОВЛЕТВОРЕН
Суд
Урус-Мартановский городской суд Чеченской Республики
Дело на странице суда
urus-martanovsky.chn.sudrf.ru
01.12.2016Передача материалов судье
01.12.2016Регистрация иска (заявления, жалобы) в суде
01.12.2016Решение вопроса о принятии иска (заявления, жалобы) к рассмотрению
05.12.2016Вынесено определение о подготовке дела к судебному разбирательству
14.12.2016Вынесено определение о назначении дела к судебному разбирательству
27.12.2016Судебное заседание
27.12.2016
Решение

Детальная проверка физлица

  • Уголовные и гражданские дела
  • Задолженности
  • Нахождение в розыске
  • Арбитражи
  • Банкротство
Подробнее