Решение по делу № 5-441/2016 от 09.12.2016

p?5????5??????e??????Y??????????V???A?????????????p??‹???????????V??????????????p??????p?????????e??????Y??????????W???A???????????????????s?????????p?????P5???????????????????!????A???K??????[??????p??e??????????V??Y??e?????[????????????????????????????Y????????????A????????????????????????Y???????????A???????????????????????A?????????л?¦???????????????????d?V??;???????V??Y??e?????[???????Ё????????????????v????????????????????h???y?????????????????????????????????????????‹??S?????A???????A???????????????‹??????(??????V???5??V???????0???????A????????0???????0?????????Y??????????????????u??????A_????U?????U???AO???????u????d?P?????:?????????????????????????????‰?????s?????????????‹?????A??????????????????!???!??Y????????????Ё????A???????????????V??Y????Y??????????????A?????????????p??9??/?h???Y????????????A?????????????????Y???????????A??????????????????????????W???A??????A?????????????????????????????????????????????j??????‹??????????????????????????????????????????????y??????P???5??????%??????????????9?????????y????????????,???????A?????‹??????????????????A‰?????s????????????????????p5?????p?????????Y??????????A???????????Y??????????A??????A????????????e?????[?????????A????????????????0?????e„A???????????????????????????????????????????y???????P???5??????%??????????????9?????????y????????????,????????????????????????‹?????????????????????????????‹???????????,‹???U?????U??????????????????????????????????‹???????????,?????????e?????????Y?????W????‹???????[??ј?Ah???Y???????????A?????????????0?????e?A?????e??????????????????????????????y???????5?????????‹??????????V????y??????????????A??????0???0?????‹??????y???????5?????????‹?????0???‹???0??U???????????y???????5?????????‹?????0????????????e?????????Y?????W????‹???????[??ј?Ah???Y???????????A?????????????0?????e?A?????e????????????????????????????????y???????5?????????‹??????????V????y??????????????A??????0???0?????‹??????y???????5?????????‹?????0???‹???0??U???????????y???????5?????????‹?????0??????????A?????‹??????????????????A‰?????s????????????????????p5?????p?????????Y??????????A???????????Y??????????A??????A????????????e?????[?????????A????????????????0?????e?A?????????????????????????????????????????????y???????P???5??????%??????????????9?????????y????????????,????????????????????????‹?????????????????????????????‹???????????,‹???U?????U??????????????????????????????????‹???????????,?????????????????‹???U??????;???????????e???????????????????????????????????????????????????????A???s???????????????????????????p5?????r???????Y??e?????[??W???????????????????????????????????Y????????????‹?????P??????????!?A€??!???e?????Y?????????S??????????????????????Y????????????‹?????p???????\w?????????????????????????????????W???????????!??????????????????????????ј?????p?????‹?????p??????????????????????????????????????????????????‹???????????,y???????A??e?????[?????????A???????????????????????????????e?A?????????????y???????P???5??????%??????????0?????????????[??U?????????????HA??Y??????t??????????????????????????????????0?????????e??????????????????????????????????y???????P???5??????%??????????????9?????????y????????????,??????S???????????0?????0?????A??????????y???????P???5??????%??????????0?????????????[??U?????????????????e????3???????‰?????????????????A????????????????????????!???!??????p???????‹???????????A????e?????[?????????????????????????????????????e??????p?????????????????????0????????????????????????y???????P???5??????%??????????????9?????????y????????????,?????????????????????????????????‹???????????,???????A?????‹?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????A???s????????????????????????€??!?????e?????Y?????????S????????????????p?????p??????????????…??????????[???????????????????????!?Aj???????[???????A?????????????????!?A€??!???e?????Y?????????S??????????????????????Y????????????‹?????p???????\w?????????????????????????????????W???????????!????????????????????????????ј?????p?????‹?????p??????????????????????????????????????????????????‹???????????,y???????A??e?????[?????????A???????????????????????????????eЇA?????????????y???????P???5??????%??????????0?????????????[??U?????????????HA??Y??????t???????v?r??‰????????Y??????[???????????????????‹??????????????????????‹??S???????????????????????????‹??????(??????V???5??V???????0???????A?????????[?????????U????????‹??S???????????????????????????‹???????????,y????????????0??A????????S??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????‹???????‹?N??????????????y???????5?????????‹?????0???y??????????Y???????????A????????????????i??y????????y???????????????P?????????????????????????????U?????????????HA??Y??????????????????????????[???????????????e????????????????????‹???????y???????5?????????‹??????????V????y??????????????A????????????0??U?????A??????????????P?????????????????????????????U?????????????????e????3???????‰?????????????????A????????????????????????!???!??????p???????‹???????????A????e?????[?????????????????????????????????????e??????p?????????????????????0????????????????????????y???????P???5??????%??????????????9?????????y????????????,?????????????????????????????????‹???????????,?????????e?????????‰???????????????e?????Aj????Y?????W?R????‹???????[???????Y???????????A?????????????0?????e??????e??????????????????????????????y???????5?????????‹??????????V????y??????????????A??????0???0?????‹??????y???????5?????????‹?????0???‹???0??U???????????y???????5?????????‹?????0????????????e?????????‰???????????????e?????Aj????Y?????W?R????‹???????[???????Y???????????A?????????????0?????e??????e???????????o????????????????????????????P???????????????????9?????5??V???????0?????????????????????A?????????????P???????????????????????U?????0??A????????????P???????????????????????A????????3???????????????????????????????????e????????t?????‹???????[?????????????j???????‹?????????????????????????????????????y???????5?????????‹??????????V????y??????????????A??????0???0?????‹??????y???????5?????????‹?????0???‹???0??U???????????y???????5?????????‹?????0????????????e?????????Y?????W???????‹???????[??ј?Ah???Y???????????A?????????????0?????e??????e???????????o????????????????????????????P???????????????????9?????5??V???????0?????????????????????A?????????????P???????????????????????U?????0??A????????????P???????????????????????A????????hN????!??????‹????????????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A????????????A?????????????j?y???‹??????????‹??????y???????5?????????‹????????t????5??V???????0????????????e??????????????????????????????‹??????y???????5?????????‹????????t????5??V???????0????????????e?????????????????‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹??????‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹????A?????‹??????y???????5?????????‹????????t????5??V???????0????????????e????????????????!‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹??????‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹??????‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹???????????!‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A??????e???????????????????????????'???s?????????????S?????????????????p????????????????A??????????y???????P???5??????%??????????????9?????????y????????????,?????????e???????????‹????????????‹???????y???????5?????????‹??????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹??????‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹???????A?????‹??????y???????5?????????‹????????t????5??V???????0???????????????????e????3???????‰?????????????????/?????‰???????????!???????????????????????j?????????s???????????p??????????p??????p??????p??????p??e?????????????y???????P???5??????%??????????????9?????????y?o??????????,?????????\???AS?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????+????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????j????????????????????????????????????????u????d?P?????:???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????W??????‹???????????????p??????p??????p??????p??????‹??S??????????????????????????????‹??????(??????V???5??V???????0???????A????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????D???????????????????+????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????j????????????????????????????????????????u????d?P?????:?????????????????????????????????????????????W?????????????????????‹???????????y???????P???5??????%??????????????????V???5??V???????0???????A??????????S??????????????????????????A??????????????????????????????p??????????????????p?????????????????????A??????a???????????????????????3???????????S????????????????‹???????y???????5?????????‹??????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹???????????????????‹??????y???????5?????????‹????????t????5??V???????0????????????e???????????????????????????‹??????y???????5?????????‹????????t????5??V???????0????????????e?????????????????????????????????A?????‹??????y???????5?????????‹????????t????5??V???????0????????????e???????????????????????‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹??????????????a‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹???????????????‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A??????????‹?????????????????e???????????????‹???A?????????????P???????????????????????V????y??????????????A????????????j?y???‹???????????????????‹??????y???????5?????????‹????????t????5??V???????0???????????????:???????????A????????????????s?????????????????????????p???p?????????????Y???V??????j???s??????????????p??????p???p?????[?????"?????w????????3???????????????????y?????????????????????????????????????‹??‹???????y???????5?????????‹??????????V????y??????????????A?????‹??????????????A???????e?????????????????????????AW??????????????????????5?????…?????Y???????????h???W??????W??????W??????W??????W?????????p??????p??????p5????????????p?????P5????????????????????Y????Y?????????????p????????????????????????????????[????????A????????????????0??Aj??????e????????????????????V??????????????????????????????y???????P???5??????%??????????????9?????????y????????????,??????????????U????????‹?????????????????????????????‹???????????,‹???U??????????????????????????????????‹???????????,????????????????e????3???????‰????????????‹??????????????????????????????????z????h????????????Ё???p??C??"y??P5??????V??Y???????????h???V???????????P??V???????????P??V?????????????p??????p?????????????p???????????????p??e?????p??e????V??Y?????????????p??????e??????????!?????????????S???????e???[??????!????????????0??j??????e???????????????????????‹?????????????????????????????‹??????(????t????????y????????????,???????[??U????[??U????????Y??????E?‹?????????????????????????????‹???????????,‹?????U??????????????????????????????????‹???????????,????????????????e????3???????‰??????????‰???????????????‰??????P????h???????‹???????????V??????e??????????!??????C????Y???????????A??????????????"u???[??U?????????e???????????????????????‹?????????????????????????????‹??????(????t????????y????????????,???????[??U????[??U????????Y??????E?‹?????????????????????????????‹???????????,‹?????U??????????????????????????????????‹???????????,?????????????‹????????????????????????Ё???p???‰????5?????…?????Y???????????h???W??????W??????W??????W??????W?????????p??????p??????p5????????????p?????P5????????????????????Y????Y?????????????p????????????????????????????????[????????A????????????????0??Aj??????e????????????????????V??????????????????????????????y???????P???5??????%??????????????9?????????y????????????,??????????????U????????‹?????????????????????????????‹???????????,‹???U??????????????????????????????????‹???????????,????????????????e????3???????‰????????????‹??????????????????????????????????z????h????????????Ё???p??C??"y??P5??????V??Y???????????h???V???????????P??V???????????P??V?????????????p??????p?????????????p???????????????p??e?????p??e????V??Y?????????????p??????e??????????!?????????????S???????e???[??????!????????????0??j??????e???????????????????????‹?????????????????????????????‹??????(????t????????y????????????,???????[??U????[??U????????Y??????E?‹?????????????????????????????‹???????????,‹?????U??????????????????????????????????‹???????????,????????????????e????3???????‰??????????‰???????????????‰??????P????h???????‹???????????V??????e??????????!??????C????Y???????????A??????????????"u???[??U?????????e???????????????????????‹?????????????????????????????‹??????(????t????????y????????????,???????[??U????[??U????????Y??????E?‹?????????????????????????????‹???????????,‹?????U??????????????????????????????????‹???????????,????????????]?I????????:????????????p????????????????????e?????AV?V????????????????????"???A???s??????????????????????????????????????e???????5????A????????????????????S???????????p???????????????????????Ё???????????????|??????N??????????????????????????????????5?????p???????e??????????E?I????????????????????;?????????????????????????????????u????????????e????????_???????o?????????????????????;???????????????????????????????????y??r????????W????????5??????I?????????:?????????????????????????U€?????????5?????????????W??W???????????p???p???5????5??????????????5????9?????????s??e?????????j??????S??????????????????????????o??????????E?I????????????????????????…???????e??????????????5????????u?????Ae??u???…??U???A…???Ae??w?????A…????I?????e?????A…??A€?u??A3???Q???????????Y??????????????????u?????Y??????????????A??Y?????????Ae???????????e???????y???????5?????????‹?????0????????????Ae??w??????????????A…??????W??????????????u?????????????0??????‹??????????????0???????????0?????????????‹??????Y???????????????????????Y?????????????t??????e?????????e???????????????Y??????????¦????????????Y?????0??????Y???????????????????????e?????U???????0?????V???????????????????????????????0????U?????U????????0?????y????‹?????3????????y???????5?????????‹?????0???y???????????A???u?????jV??j????P?y????????I?????????????U????5?????S?????u?????jV??j????P?y????????I???????????????????????e???????????????????ў??I??????????????????I????????V??j????F???????I???????????????????????????????????????????????u??????????f????????????????A????I??????5????????Y????ё????????????????????u??????????????????????????????????????????????????????I?????????????????????????????????????????????I?????????????????????O???????????I????????[1]?w??????y?????????????????????????????f??????f??‰??????????????????e???????????????????????j?????????????????????u????AjV??????????????????????????e????????j???????????I?????????W????????????j????A????????????ї?????????u??????W??????????????j???????f????????????j???????P??A??????????????????u????AjV????????e?????????????????????e????????j?????????e????????????j????????AC?Ae??????j????A?C?A@??A?????A??~?????u??????????????????????u??[1]?y??????????????I?????????W?????????j?????‰???e????????u????????????????jV???????????T??T??S?????u??????V????????????????C??????????????????e??????????????u??????3????????????????f??‰?????????????????????????????P????P??X????At??????????????????????AC?A?‰??[1]j??????S??????????Ah[1]??????I????????????€?T?Є?Є??A??????????u?????A3w?????????????????????????A???????????????????3????????????????????????????????3????????????‰?e??E????‹???????h???????P?????????????????????????????????????j????f????????????A?Ё?????????????????A3??A…????o_??A???'C?????|????????????AP??e?????I????????:??????????????????????A??????????f???????????????????????p?????/????????????a????????????E?I??????????‹?Au?????????????????????????????????'-????????‹?Ae?????A…???Ae??w?????????????????I??????????????????…????e???I????????????????????u???AP???5?????????S?????‹??C???????AP???5??????‹?A…???Ae??w???????A…?????????????I??????????y???S?????e??????ј?A‹?A…???????????P????????Ae??u????????D?u??‹‰???????????????????????A‰?Au???P????????AjO???Ay?????A…??????w??????????????P???????????????V???????#????I??????A?:?????????????????????b??P??????????????€?????????††??????Ў???????????????????????????????????????????%y??????????Y???f?????f??????????????*?????a??????????a?????????????????????????[1]????????f????????†???o??????????????????м??????????????????Џ?????†????o??????o????j???V???????????????м??????????????????Џ????Б?????????????????????????A??????†????????????????????y?????????????????????????W???????y???????????y??P5????5????????????S??м?????????????????????????????j???????????????????U?????????C????????y????????????A???????????????????A??AC?a???C??????????f??f??????????????????????C?Ё??????y????????f??‹???????????‹?????? ???j??????C?Ё????????????????f??f??????y???????????????AC?a????????????????e?????????????????????????Y???????????????????AA????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????"????????????????????!??????????????????????????A‹?????????????????P5?????????????????????????????DI???€???+??????????????????????"?????A?????????o????????A‰?????%??????y
?????????y???????????‹????A‰???????-?A???????????Q????+????5????????????f??f????????????????????????????#?????????[??/????????????????'?l??????yA??????????????????????(??????????C????????y??j???????????A??????5?????????????a??????f??????C????A?????????????C?Ё??A??????????¤???‰????????????????????????C?A?????????????E?h????Y????????ho???????e??????????????????A?:??????????????????????????????@???‰??????????????0‰?????????s?????????Y??????‹?????e???S??…???????e???????W???????????j?????????s??????s???????????????€??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????П???/???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????e????Y???????????????p????????g???????‹????????e??????V??????????e?????????p??????p?????????????d????????????????5???????”?????????????????????e?????????e??????????e??????????????????????????????????????????????????